The Top 5 Overdue Extreme Reunions
Wednesday, May 21st, 2008I’m not one of those bitter old cunts who always moans about how new music sucks and nothing will ever beat the bands I grew up with. I mean, have you heard the new Ashlee Simpson record? Shit is transcendent! That said, the desperate, pathetic avarice of The Reunion Tour (And/Or Album) always makes for a good time, especially when you’re drunk enough to not care about how desperate and pathetic all participants on and offstage truly are. So why am I writing about five extreme (-ish) bands I’d like to see reform when said five have thus far preserved their integrity and legacy by bravely focusing on the unwritten future as opposed to the security of the past? I dunno, Albert told me to.
Faith No More (Angel Dust era)
WHAT’S THE HOLDUP?
You haven’t seen a band not give a shit until you’ve seen YouTube clips of FNM playing Album of the Year material. Also, Mike Patton only likes choruses these days when Norah Jones is involved.
WOULD THEY STILL “BRING IT” ONSTAGE?
See above. Hard to imagine Mike pinballing around à la the 1992 “Hangin’ With MTV” performance of “Midlife Crisis” and “Caffeine.”
BUT REALLY, WOULD A NEW RECORD BE ANY GOOD?
Only the Great Pumpkin knows for sure, and only Jim Martin knows if the Great Pumpkin truly exists. This quandary will never be resolved, so why bother speculating?
Helmet (Meantime era)
WHAT’S THE HOLDUP?
Based on the fact that John Stanier and Henry Bogdan declined an opportunity to participate in a Meantime (or Strap It On; either would work) Hall of Fame, we assume there might be the teensiest bit of acrimony with founder Page Hamilton.
WOULD THEY STILL “BRING IT” ONSTAGE?
Regardless of what you think about Size Matters or Monochrome, Hamilton’s not given up the Helmet dream, so any current YouTube clip is indicative of what you’ll get. We still maintain that Stanier (doing just fine in Battles) was an irreplaceable weapon.
BUT REALLY, WOULD A NEW RECORD BE ANY GOOD?
Did you like Aftertaste? It’d probably sound like that.
Kyuss
WHAT’S THE HOLDUP?
Homme is amusingly kind of pumped that everybody missed the boat the first time, and Garcia and Bjork seem happy enough with their current small-scale projects. Nick Oliveri: kind of a wild card, in case you haven’t heard.
WOULD THEY STILL “BRING IT” ONSTAGE?
If Garcia still wore camo pants and Homme brought back the Skeet Ulrich bob, fucking-a right they would.
BUT REALLY, WOULD A NEW RECORD BE ANY GOOD?
It’s easy to be skeptical when individual members release underwhelming or repetitive solo albums, and the bloom has sorta faded from QOTSA’s rose. Recapturing the magic: doubtful.
Godflesh
WHAT’S THE HOLDUP?
Maybe we should give Broadrick a few more years of not flipping out/cancelling tours before we demand something of this magnitude.
WOULD THEY STILL “BRING IT” ONSTAGE?
If Justin wore a Jesu tank top, definitely.
BUT REALLY, WOULD A NEW RECORD BE ANY GOOD?
Broadrick doesn’t have much of a track record for putting out dogshit. If it weren’t mastered at blow-out-your-cochlea Fall Out Boy level, it’d probably kill.
Botch
WHAT’S THE HOLDUP?
Rightly seeing into the future of a billion math-metal bands unabashedly ripping them off, they called it quits after posthumous EP An Anthology of Dead Ends, figuring there wasn’t much left to accomplish in the genre.
WOULD THEY STILL “BRING IT” ONSTAGE?
Um, yes.
BUT REALLY, WOULD A NEW RECORD BE ANY GOOD?
They think it wouldn’t, but they’re wrong.



















